Coupang's User Recovery Amid 900 Billion Won Fines and Regulatory Challenges


Coupang has effectively recovered the number of users that had declined following a massive data breach, but regulatory sanctions and legal battles continue. Customer metrics have rebounded, with the number of paid Wow members reaching an all-time high, yet the fines imposed by the Personal Information Protection Commission and the Fair Trade Commission this year have exceeded 900 billion won (KRW). The ongoing conflict over the designation of Coupang Inc. Chairman Kim Beom-seok as the sole representative adds to the uncertainty in management.
 
According to app and retail analysis service WiseApp & Retail, Coupang's monthly active users (MAU) in October were recorded at 34,309,109, which is 99.7% of the level just before the data breach in November of last year (34,398,407). Notably, the user count, which had dropped to 33,123,043 in February, has since increased by 1,186,066 over the past eight months. The number of Wow members has also surged to a record high. Chairman Kim stated during the third-quarter earnings conference call on November 4 that "the increase in Wow membership is due to the return of existing members and the influx of new members compared to the same period last year and the previous quarter."
 
Despite the recovery in customer metrics, regulatory burdens remain. The Personal Information Protection Commission imposed a fine of 624.68 billion won (KRW) in June for the data breach and unauthorized collection of users' online activity records. Of this, the fine related to the data breach amounted to 423.57 billion won (KRW), while the fine for unauthorized collection of activity records was 201.11 billion won (KRW). Legal proceedings regarding the fines are ongoing. On November 5, the court rejected a request to suspend the enforcement of the fine related to the data breach of over 423.57 billion won (KRW). Conversely, on November 6, the enforcement of the fine related to the unauthorized collection of activity records, amounting to over 201.11 billion won (KRW), was suspended until 30 days after the first-instance ruling on the main case. The final burden may change depending on the outcome of both cases.

 

 
The Fair Trade Commission has also added to the sanctions. On November 9, the commission decided to impose a fine of 300.8 billion won (KRW) on Coupang Eats for requiring partner companies to agree to transaction conditions that were the same as or more favorable than those offered by other delivery applications. This fine is a provisional amount, and a confirmation process remains. When combined with the fines from the Personal Information Protection Commission, the total reaches 925.48 billion won (KRW). Additionally, the Fair Trade Commission is expected to reassess whether the bundling of the Wow membership with Coupang Eats and Coupang Play services constitutes unfair tying.
 
The conflict surrounding Chairman Kim's designation as the sole representative is also a variable. The Fair Trade Commission changed Coupang's sole representative designation from the corporation to Chairman Kim in April, but the court suspended the effect of this decision in July. Coupang maintains that Chairman Kim and his relatives do not hold shares in domestic affiliates, eliminating concerns over private benefit extraction. The Fair Trade Commission's secretariat has reportedly sent a review report suggesting that Coupang and Chairman Kim should be prosecuted for allegedly submitting false designation materials and has initiated a review process. The issue of whether Chairman Kim's brother, Kim Yoo-seok, is involved in the management of domestic affiliates remains a point of contention.
 
An industry insider noted, "The recovery of user numbers after the data breach indicates that Coupang's customer base remains solid," but added, "With the potential for large fines and additional sanctions, how much legal uncertainty can be resolved will be a crucial variable for future management."




* This article has been translated by AI.