[Editorial] 'Nemo judex in causa sua'... Special Counsel for Personal Cases Should Be Handled by Others


‘Nemo judex in causa sua’. This means that one should not adjust their shoes in an orchard or fix their hat under a plum tree. It serves as a warning to avoid actions that could lead to suspicion, not just to refrain from wrongdoing. This caution is especially pertinent for a special counsel.
 
On November 19, President Lee Jae-myung re-signed the 'manipulated prosecution special counsel law.' The law took effect immediately upon promulgation. Of the 12 cases under investigation, half, or six, are related to the investigation and prosecution processes of cases for which President Lee is being prosecuted.
 
The final selection of the special counsel is also made by President Lee. The Democratic Party, People Power Party, and Rebuilding Korea Party each recommend one candidate, and the president appoints one from among the three. This structure means that the person investigating whether the prosecution of criminal cases related to the president was manipulated is ultimately chosen by the president himself.
 
The law includes the long-standing principle that 'no one can be a judge in their own case (Nemo judex in causa sua).' This concern has also been present in our special counsel history.
 
A representative example is the special counsel for the Park Geun-hye administration's corruption scandal in 2016. At that time, the possibility that President Park could be a subject of investigation meant that the ruling party, the Saenuri Party, was not granted the right to recommend special counsel candidates. The two opposition parties, the Democratic Party and the People's Party, agreed to recommend two candidates, and President Park appointed lawyer Park Young-soo from among them.
 
The Constitutional Court also recognized this. In February 2019, the court unanimously ruled that if the ruling party participated in recommending special counsel candidates, it could lead to a conflict of interest, which could undermine the purpose of the special counsel system. Given that the president could be a subject of investigation, there was a reasonable basis for excluding the ruling party from the recommendation process.
 
The Constitutional Court emphasized that the basis for its ruling was 'various safeguards to ensure the political neutrality and independence of the special counsel.' Ultimately, what the court sought to protect was not the form of the recommendation right but the degree of independence the special counsel has from the power being investigated.
 
A similar situation occurred during the Lee Myung-bak administration. The special counsel law regarding the allegations of the purchase of land for Lee Myung-bak's private residence in Naegok-dong allowed the then-opposition Democratic Party to recommend two candidates, from which President Lee appointed one.
 
Of course, the direct subject of investigation under the manipulated prosecution special counsel law is not President Lee himself. However, it does not change the fact that he is a direct stakeholder in the matter. In such cases, power should take a step back.
 
There have been precedents in the past. Former President Kim Dae-jung was sentenced to death in 1980 for the 'Kim Dae-jung conspiracy incident' fabricated by the military junta. Although those involved were later acquitted in retrials, President Kim did not request a retrial during his presidency. He stated that he did not request a retrial while in office to consider the burden on the judiciary. Ultimately, he was acquitted of the conspiracy charges in 2004.
 
The manipulated prosecution special counsel law is already in effect. The president cannot change the recommendation structure set by the National Assembly. Now, what remains for President Lee is to choose from the candidates recommended by the three parties. At least at this final stage, he should adhere to the 'political neutrality and independence' emphasized by the Constitutional Court. He should select someone who is the most distant from him, rather than the closest, someone who will be recognized for their independence as a legal expert over political interests.
 
However, before the special counsel investigation even began, President Lee publicly stated that he had been harmed by 'excessive investigations and prosecutions for political purposes.' In the Wirye incident, he claimed that the prosecution presented evidence that had been 'altered.' In this way, the president, who is the most directly involved party and the appointing authority, has already made a judgment on the 'manipulation' that the special counsel is supposed to uncover.
 
At this point, rather than adhering to 'Nemo judex in causa sua,' we should be concerned about the reverse of the proverb, 'adjusting shoes in an orchard and fixing a hat under a plum tree.' It is akin to unnecessarily adjusting one's shoes in an orchard and fixing one's hat under a plum tree.



* This article has been translated by AI.