Impeachment of Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae Underway Amid Controversy

The Democratic Party is moving forward with the impeachment of Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae, prompted by the Supreme Court's ruling on the appeal of former Prime Minister Han Dong-soo regarding a rebellion case. To use the full bench's ruling as grounds for impeachment, it must be specifically established what actions by Chief Justice Cho violated the constitution or laws during the proceedings and verdict.


On the 20th, the Democratic Party formed an impeachment committee led by lawmaker Yang Boo-nam. The committee will review the grounds for impeachment and the schedule for the motion. The party plans to adopt the impeachment initiative as its official stance during a general meeting of lawmakers later that afternoon. Democratic Party leader Kim Min-seok stated during a party YouTube broadcast that "the accumulation of constitutional and legal violations as grounds for impeachment existed before yesterday's decision."


The Supreme Court's full bench overturned the original ruling, which sentenced former Prime Minister Han to 15 years in prison for charges related to rebellion, and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court. The nine justices who issued the majority opinion found it difficult to recognize the purpose of constitutional violation in Han's actions of proposing a cabinet meeting and summoning cabinet members before the declaration of martial law. However, they accepted the original ruling's judgment regarding actions taken after the declaration of martial law.


Three dissenting justices argued that when considering actions before and after the declaration of martial law, the proposal for a cabinet meeting prior to the declaration could also be recognized as having a purpose of constitutional violation. Justice Oh Kyung-mi, reading the dissenting opinion, stated, "In a presidential coup, acts that destroy constitutional order manifest themselves in the guise of normal and official administrative actions of the state." The Supreme Court also renewed Han's detention period by two months.


Rejection of Request for Reconsideration and Budget Execution: What Actions Will Be Included in the Impeachment Motion?

If the Democratic Party includes the ruling on former Prime Minister Han in the grounds for impeachment, the issue will be whether any actions by Chief Justice Cho during the full bench's proceedings and ruling violated the constitution or laws.


The Democratic Party initially planned to investigate the rejection of requests for reconsideration of Supreme Court justice candidates, improper execution of operational expenses, and allegations of cash payments for encouraging justices through a national investigation. The impeachment motion proposed by the Rebuilding Korea Party last month included these issues along with the process of the Supreme Court's remand in President Lee Jae-myung's election law case. The rejection of requests for reconsideration raises the question of whether Chief Justice Cho had a legal obligation to respond to such requests, while the budget execution allegations could hinge on whether proper grounds and procedures were followed for expenditures.


The People Power Party criticized the push for impeachment of the head of the judiciary based on the ruling, stating it undermines the separation of powers and judicial independence. The presidential office denied reports of prior consultations with the Democratic Party. Chief Justice Cho did not respond to reporters' questions about the impeachment initiative during his commute to work that morning.


If Passed by the National Assembly, Authority Will Be Suspended: Senior Justice Will Act in Place

According to Article 65 of the Constitution, an impeachment motion against the Chief Justice must be proposed by at least one-third of the members of the National Assembly and must be approved by a majority of the members present to pass. Based on a total of 299 members, 100 votes are needed for the proposal and 150 votes for approval. The Democratic Party holds 161 seats. If the motion is not referred to the Legislation and Judiciary Committee by the plenary session, it will be voted on anonymously within 24 to 72 hours after being reported to the plenary session.


If the impeachment motion is passed and the impeachment resolution is delivered, Chief Justice Cho's exercise of authority will be suspended. A senior justice will act in his place, and courts at all levels will continue their proceedings. Whether the appointment of justices can proceed under the acting authority will be a point of contention.


The Constitutional Court will determine whether there were any violations of the constitution or laws during Chief Justice Cho's performance of duties and whether such violations are serious enough to warrant dismissal. A majority of six or more justices is required for dismissal.


Chief Justice Cho is also facing the variable of his retirement next June. The Constitutional Court dismissed a petition for impeachment against former Busan High Court Chief Judge Lim Sung-keun in 2021, stating that he could not be dismissed as he had already retired due to the expiration of his term. If the impeachment motion against Chief Justice Cho is passed, it will mark the first case of the Constitutional Court adjudicating the impeachment of a chief justice.





* This article has been translated by AI.